FluencyLab

GrammarHub

B2 Pre-advanced
B2 grammar contents
B2Relative clauses

Defining and non-defining relative clauses

Control relative pronoun choice, omission, punctuation, preposition placement and whole-clause reference in defining and non-defining structures.

Overview

What this grammar does

Control relative pronoun choice, omission, punctuation, preposition placement and whole-clause reference in defining and non-defining structures.

Form and rules

How it works

1

Defining clauses identify the noun and normally have no commas; non-defining clauses add extra information and are set off by commas.

2

That can replace who/which in many defining clauses but not normally in non-defining clauses or directly after a preposition.

3

Object relative pronouns can be omitted in defining clauses; subject pronouns and pronouns in non-defining clauses cannot be omitted.

4

Formal preposition placement uses preposition + whom/which; conversational English often strands the preposition at the end.

5

Which can refer to an entire previous clause in a non-defining structure: He arrived late, which annoyed everyone.

A closer look

Meaning and use

Formal preposition placement uses preposition + whom/which; conversational English often strands the preposition at the end.

Which can refer to an entire previous clause in a non-defining structure: He arrived late, which annoyed everyone.

Examples

See the pattern in complete sentences

The candidate who scored highest got the job.

My manager, who joined in May, is leaving.

The proposal (that) we discussed was rejected.

The person to whom I spoke was helpful.

The server crashed again, which delayed the launch.

Common mistakes

What to avoid

The report where we discussed yesterday has been revised.
The report that we discussed yesterday has been revised.

An object relative in a defining clause can use that and could be omitted.

My laptop, that I bought last year, has stopped working.
My laptop, which I bought last year, has stopped working.

A non-defining thing clause uses which and cannot omit it.

Ready to practise?

The test combines multiple choice, gap completion, error correction, and sentence building so students have to recognise and produce the grammar, not simply reread the rule.